LYME SCI: Dog maps provide important clue to human disease risk
“One Health” is the concept that human health, animal health and the health of the environment are all connected. And that it’s important to understand and address health issues in each of these arenas—in order to solve the problems of all.
An important example of this is when you compare maps of canine Lyme disease risk to the CDC’s maps of human risk of the illness.
One problem with the maps of human cases lies with the CDC’s restrictive reporting criteria. Their maps severely underrepresent the true risk of Lyme and other tick-borne diseases.
Because tick-borne diseases can also cause severe illness in dogs, cats, horses and other livestock, veterinary records may offer a clearer picture of which tick-borne diseases are occurring within a geographic region.
Recently, a group of researchers used veterinary data to predict the incidence of Lyme disease and two other common tick-borne illnesses, Ehrlichiosis and Anaplasmosis, within the US.
The canary in the coal mine
According to Michael Yabsley, a parasitologist at the University of Georgia, “Dogs really are the canary in the coal mine for human infection. Our research team has growing evidence that the relationship between risk of canine infection and human disease is strong.”
Fortunately, many dogs are screened for exposure to tick-borne diseases during their annual test for heartworm. These screenings provided researchers a unique opportunity to examine test results from nearly 12 million pets from 2011 to 2015, allowing them to paint a comprehensive, county-by-county picture across the nation.
The researchers combined veterinary test results, US census data and imagery, along with weather forecasts, to create a risk map for these tick-borne diseases. (This kind of graphic representation is called a “heat map.”)
Dogs have year-round exposure
Dogs are at greater risk for Lyme and other tick-borne diseases because they spend time outdoors every day. For that reason, dog owners are also at higher risk if their pets bring ticks home.
Ticks have a two-year life cycle and in warmer climates are active year-round. Even in areas with cold winters, ticks can become active whenever temperatures rise above freezing.
Veterinarians recommend that pets be protected from fleas and ticks year-round. Robert Lund, PhD, a professor at Clemson University, says “the bottom line is simple: Parasites pose threats to both pets and people no matter the season, and it’s important to guard against them.”
Four tests in one
One of the most interesting aspects of the study was the blood test they used. The canine test is called “Lab 4Dx Plus Test” and is made by IDEXX Laboratories. The Lab 4Dx detects antibodies for the following pathogens in one blood sample:
- Heartworm
- Lyme disease
- Anaplasma phagocytophilum
- Anaplasma platys
- Ehrlichia ewingii
- Ehrlichia canis
According researcher Dr. Susan E. Little, “A minimum sensitivity of 90% and a minimum specificity of 90% are required for all canine tick-borne disease antibody assays.”
(If we could adapt this technology to human medicine, it would be one of the most helpful diagnostic tools I can imagine! The sensitivity and specificity of “standard” Lyme tests for humans fall woefully short of that requirement.)
Risk of tick bites is coast to coast
Based on many environmental factors, the Companion Animal Parasite Council (CAPC) forecasts that Lyme disease will be highly problematic in 2017. Nationwide, Lyme disease continues to spread into new areas every year and is now established in 50% of all US counties.
Lyme disease is endemic along the Atlantic coast from Washington DC to Maine, and the upper Midwest. The highest incidence occurs in Pennsylvania, New Jersey, New York, Wisconsin, Minnesota, Maryland, Rhode Island, Delaware, Massachusetts, Connecticut, Maine, New Hampshire, Vermont and Delaware.
The map shows the estimated number of dogs that will test positive for Lyme disease. For instance, in the red areas, it’s estimated that anywhere from 10% to 100% of dogs will test positive for Lyme. The darker the blue, the lower the risk.
CAPC does not forecast any changes in the prevalence of Anaplasmosis for 2017. High risk areas remain: Northern California, Western Pennsylvania, Wisconsin, Minnesota and New York State. The map shows the estimated percentage of dogs that will test positive for Anaplasma.
Ehrlichia is geographically very spotty, going from non-existent to endemic within a 200-mile range. Overall, the forecast prevalence for Ehrlichiosis will be higher than normal through much of the southern US.
Eastern Oklahoma is expected to see a very active year in 2017, and the Ohio River Valley, Virginia, North Carolina, Eastern Oregon and Western Montana will see increased activity. The map shows the estimated percentage of dogs that will test positive for Ehrlichiosis.
Symptoms of Lyme disease
According to the American Veterinary Medical Association (AVMA), dogs may not show symptoms of Lyme for two to five months after exposure. Canine symptoms include:
- Fever
- Loss of appetite
- Lameness
- Joint swelling
- Decreased activity
* (see here for symptoms in other animals)
Pets need year-round protection
The Tick Management Handbook, published by the Connecticut Agricultural Experiment Station, offers several recommendations for protecting your yard and your pets:
Perimeter fencing: keeps pets in and deer out
- Perimeter barrier: dry wood chips, pebbles or xeriscaping
- Spray perimeter with acaricide: kills ticks
- Tick collars (amitraz impregnated): prevents the ticks from climbing on the pet
- Monthly topical “spot on” (permethrin) application: kills the tick if it bites the pet*
- Monthly topical spray (Fipronil) application: kills the tick if it bites the pet
- Monthly oral medication: kills the tick if it bites the pet
- Daily tick checks
- canine Lyme vaccine: offers protection from one tick-borne disease
*Note: Permethrin is not safe for cats. (see AVMA recommendations here)
In Summary
From the data, the researchers estimate the risk for Anaplasma will remain relatively unchanged from 2015. The risk for Ehrlichia will be higher than normal, and the risk for Lyme disease will be significantly higher than in past years.
If you own a pet, CPAC advises that one of the best ways to protect yourself from Lyme and other tick-borne diseases it to protect your pet by taking year-round preventive measures.
Interactive Sentinel Map
To see how many cases of canine Lyme disease, Ehrlichiosis or Anaplasmosis have been confirmed in your neighborhood, go to this interactive map and type in your zip code.
LymeSci is written by Lonnie Marcum, a Licensed Physical Therapist and mother of a daughter with Lyme. Follow her on Twitter: @LonnieRhea Email her at: lmarcum@lymedisease.org .
As usual, this is inaccurate. I live as far west as you can go in Washington state. I have anaplasmosis and enough reactive bands to be suspicious for Lyme. There are ticks in our backyard. The squirrels are full of them.
Not sure why the map of Northern California is projected to be so low given that 30 to 40% of the adults in NorCal are probably infected. I think there is a grand underestimation of the true numbers infected because so many are asymptomatic at any one time. With other pandemics, such as TB, 90% are asymptomatic. Not directly comparing this with Borreliosis but you get the idea.
You know what the shame is?? Dogs get treated better then human beings in USA.
I always have to point out: the data for Sonoma County CA (north Bay Area) is wrong. CAPC is aware and simply omitted one company’s data rather than try to get correct data. So we are under-reported, probably by a lot.
Also, all three maps use different scales so you can’t compare relative prevalence of the three diseases.
The test is a C6 peptide test, which also exists for humans but not at the sensitivity that Dr. Little quotes here.
In 2003 my dog died from tic- paralysis. Same year my 15 yr old daughter became sick with flu like symptoms. She was not diagnosed with Lyme till 6 yrs later. Today she is suffering from Lyme NeuroBorreliosis. Maybe If had taken her to a vet she would have been diagnosed sooner.
Wondering how much population density and therefore numbers of dogs figure into this. The map uses number of dogs, and there are going to be a lot more of them in more populated areas, thus showing low risk in northern CA but high risk in NJ. Somehow there ought to be a way to adjust for the great differences in population, so that unpopulated areas do not seem to be safe.
Lyme in pets and almost killed me in 2005 , now treating one of my 2 dogs for anaplasmosis ! Am an RN and unable to work since 2004 Constant chills and pain and have a conservative PCP who teaches at Harvard Medical and does not believe in chronic Lyme and misdiagnosed as fibromyalgia and still stubborn about treatment even with my photos I sent to him of jars full of ticks in alcohol and rashes and now my heart and soul dog being treated for anaplasmosis !
I am wondering Babiosis and Bartonella weren’t tracked as well?
My 2 dogs got ticks from a dog that came from AZ desert. I was bitten TWICE by ticks from my own dogs. I did everything I could to get rid of dogs ticks but because there were 2 of them (hosting) it was almost impossible (they both died). I knew I had been bitten BUT the media refers to them as deer ticks and I never though I would get Lyme. Doctors IN NV and AZ claim NO ticks here and of course NO LYME either. I wish then what I know now. I got antibiotics from Mexico.
Had I had access to better information I would not be plagued with the disease. Extremely unfortunate. News seems to only cover Ebola and ZIKA. YES I have Lyme but it was never reported in NV. I will not die from it but from what it continues to do to my organs.
Does anyone know why certain counties have no data? We live in L.A. County and frequent Ventura County a lot but I truly feel my 9-year-old daughter was bitten in Mono County. She came down with the flu-like illness 6 weeks after hiking in Mammoth from Devil’s Postpile to Rainbow Falls (ideal tick habitat). This was followed by migratory joint pain, fatigue, headache, weakness, stomach ache, shooting pains, etc. She got strep, had a herx from amoxicillin (unbeknownst to us or any doctors), then neuropsychiatric problems. It took nearly a year to diagnose and she is CDC positive for Lyme plus positive for babesia, bartonella, erlichia, mycoplasma (and more). Plus diagnosed with PANDAS. Anyhow, my husband did end up seeing a sign posted at one of our local trails indicating that the ticks in the area carry lyme and co but I still have that feeling about Mono County. (The counties right next door have higher levels of dogs infected too). The reason I wonder and worry is because I think that the tourists and locals alike in Mammoth should be aware that lyme and co is a possibility there. I actually contacted a local vet there and they said they don’t test their dogs for lyme because they vaccinate them all against lyme. (Guess that answers my question)….but I assume they would only vaccinate them all because it is a true threat in that area…?? Maybe I’ll never know. At least my daughter is healing but I don’t want others to suffer!
We live in AZ. Our German Shepherd had ticks behind his ears and my two children and I got infected with Lyme disease, Bartonella Henselae and Erlichia. We have fought to get proper treatment and it went to later stages with all three of us. We also developed brain autoimmunity. I wish more people with dogs would realize their ticks can carry many infections.